Wednesday, November 24, 2010

The peer review process

I think oftentimes we as human beings do not like the review process because it entails criticism just by its very nature. However, it has been my personal experience that the feed back I receive from others has often allowed me to see things from a perspective I may not have considered. Perhaps it is like talking to a neutral party about a crisis you may be facing in your life; you may not like or even agree with what is being said but it allows you to see things differently. This is the same with writing. When a person writes they are often seeing things from only one perspective, theirs, and thus cannot see where errors may have occured or possible new information may be added (or deleted). for this reason I am a fan of peer review because by looking at things in a different light the point you yourself are trying to make may be able to be done more effectively.

1 comment:

  1. Hi Gail, 25 Nov 10

    Happy Thanksgiving to you and your family!

    I tend to agree with you to an extent on the peer review process; it is good to see others' perspective on how they (as the reader) are able to understand what is being stated and to know that the point being discussed is understood or not understood.

    As of today I have not received feedback on my current "First Draft", but I can tell you in past experience, peer review has not worked so well. And here I go again, I am going to agree with you, that some students are stand-off-ish when it comes to giving criticism for fear of not being understood correctly or causing friction.

    I am not a fan of peer review, but it does not mean that I have closed the door to the concept and opportunities.

    I know my paper still needs re-worked and I will do just that. Maybe you would be able to provide some honest constructive criticism on my submitted paper.

    Our linked response for this blog is that I agree with peer review only on the basis of hearing how a different perspective can shed light on what is or is not understood.

    Happy writing,

    Julie Atkins
    HST

    ReplyDelete